Earth Day Gift: A Properly Darwinian Religion

Allow me to give you an Earth Day gift I’ve been trying to wrap up ever since I studied under an eminent Thoreau scholar who, in his first lecture, handed it to me—by saying:

“For Thoreau, nature was a symbol.”

“A symbol of what?” I blurted, admittedly interrupting but…come on: a symbol?

“Of God, of course,” he replied, smiling scrutinously; “What did you think?”

“Well, I’m not sure, but if he wanted to write about God, why didn’t he just write about God and leave nature alone? Seems like ….”

“It’s pleasing to know,” he interjected, “some of us will learn something this semester.”

That was it; he returned to his lecture.

Screen Shot 2014-04-22 at 5.05.33 PM

I asked the question because I hoped to use my grad-school time at UConn to learn about nature; and if America’s greatest nature writer didn’t write about nature except as a symbol of God, then how was I going to learn about it?

Answer: First, I got elected as an inland wetlands commissioner for the town of Chaplin, CT, a position that compelled me to study ecology, environmental history, law and politics. Second, I taught environmental history and philosophy for a full year with a grad student from the Ecology and Evolutionary Dept. Through these educations, I learned what nature is according to science, law and politics.

I also learned of the abyss between Thoreau’s definition of nature as spirited and science’s definition of nature as a quantifiable, predictable & manipulatable subject. My teaching collaborator, Ricardo Rozzi, cultivated an extensive knowledge of evolutionary theory, conservation biology, and of Darwin’s journals, especially those written while Darwin was on the Beagle exploring the Cape Horn region that is now part of Chile. Reading Darwin after Thoreau was a revelation, because Darwin was trained to view nature as a symbol of God (he’d considered becoming a priest), but his career as a scientist caused to abandon that theological view. His abandonment epitomizes the split between theological and scientific definitions of nature. As a commissioner I was not empowered to use theology to evaluate impacts proposed impacts upon wetlands; objections to impacts had to be grounded in science, and in law. And when I hung out with ecology grad students and professors the theological definition of nature was acknowledged but avoided, so for it had long been wrung out of academic science. That isn’t to say these folks didn’t harbor spiritual connections to nature; it is to say that the language and worldview of their discipline did not harbor it. When they did their sciencey work, theirs was a mechanical nature, not symbol of God or the living luscious flesh of Venus.

sacred camphor tree nara
sacred camphor tree
Nara, Japan

Our law and our science do not recognize the spiritual reality of nature, and our lawyers and scientists—& everybody—are “free” to ignore the bio-ethics and behaviors that attends such recognition. The gift I give now, recognizes it.

Nature is that which gives birth; and what the word denotes—the permanent birthing process of the present moment that is sacred b/c we are alive in it—is actually beyond the ability of our language to express. Our minds cannot comprehend all of nature, and because we can’t comprehend it, “nature” remains mythological. Every culture has a mythology that explains, as best it can, the permanent birthing process of the present moment.

Screen Shot 2014-04-22 at 4.05.34 PM

In western Christian culture, theological and scientific views of nature have harmonized, such as in the shared presumption that human beings are uniquely appointed to rule over the other creatures on the earth, and that stones and clouds and oceans etc are not alive. Catholics have the history of Galileo and the Inquisition, but they also have St. Thomas whose doctrine of natural law—that God’s presence and laws can be adduced through science—is sanctified. Protestantism gave us Thoreau, but it also gave us the Calvinist bibliolator, also known as the Christian fundamentalist.

Screen Shot 2014-04-22 at 5.21.29 PM

Charles Darwin carefully avoided theology in his published writings, because the greatest resistance to his theories came from Protestant fundamentalists, who held strictly to the story of Genesis. Industrialists and bankers approved of Darwin’s theory of evolution, on the other hand, for it formed the basis for the science of biology, and consequent rise of big industries. Hospitals with their antibiotics, supermarkets with their factory farm foods and clothing stores with their cotton sprayed with pesticides: all are products of Darwin’s theory.

How many evolution deniers go to hospitals and eat at McDonalds without knowing they’d be naked, sick and starving without it?

Darwinism is ubiquitous. We would not be able to recognize reality without it. It is Monsanto and Tyson Foods, Pfizer and Syngenta, Banana Republic and Ralph Lauren. It’s our prescriptions and our surgeries. Corn chips, cheese doodles and Coke.

Darwin’s strategy of avoiding theology proved successful, at least for the medical profession, farmers, industrialists and bankers. It’s had a regrettable effect, though, on the cultures that embrace it because the religious awakening that would attend a working out of a theology of evolution, and an attendant ethic, never happens. So, allow me to present a few basic tenets of a properly Darwinian religion.

1)    What is known as “spirit” in theology is, to our properly Darwinian religion, life or bios.

2)    “Eternal life” occurs through the transmission of genes through “endless” generations.

3)    Life is shared, here & now, by all species.

4)    Life is shared, over time, by all species.

5)    This shared life is called the long body. We, & our ancestors past and future, live in it. It is sacred; it is holy: we are alive in it.

6)    The long body is not a tribal deity, or projection of collective or personal ego. It is not the “environment” either, but can be partially envisioned as a biome.

7)    It is the subject of science, perceivable any given moment as reality.

8)    It is what language (literal, biological & physical) partially reproduces without comprehending.

9)    It hums and glows in the skies and our veins and oceans.

10)  It needs sufficient water, solar radiation and soil—and cannot be severed long from them.

11)  It can be killed.

12)  It can be grown.

The theology of the long body is expressed through action, not words: via inhabitation. It has an ethic, a system of right and wrong behavior, which I’ll describe next.

 

About the author

Subscribe to Biocitizen Banter

Biocitizen Blogs

RSS Westhampton, MA

  • The River and the Machine: A Biocultural History of Holyoke Dam February 11, 2021
    WHAT IS BIOCITIZEN? The word “biocitizen” is a contraction of “biotic citizen,” a term and idea conceived by Aldo Leopold (1887–1948) who is widely celebrated for conceiving the “land ethic.” A thing is right when it tends to preserve the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community. It is wrong when it tends otherwise. A […]
  • Biocitizen MA Welcomes Charlie Schine, FEP teacher! December 31, 2020
    Charlie is a recent graduate from Wesleyan University who is just beginning to get his footing in the big wide world and figure out where he’s going. Although he majored in music, his studies always seemed to circle around environmentalism and the more-than-human world, a cross pollination which began the summer after his freshman year […]

RSS Los Angeles, CA

  • CLAWS BLOG: Wind Wolves Preserve – Camping | Hiking | Stewardship December 1, 2021
    Wind Wolves Preserve Camping | Hiking | Native Plant Stewardship FRIDAY Our second CLAWS trip of the fall kicked off at our normal meeting point Bette Davis Park. Folks were excited to get things going, so after an opening circle, with introductions, a gear check, and the plan for the evening we officially started our […]
  • Fear, Growth, and Success! A story of overcoming challenges with Biocitizen LA October 24, 2021
    Lead Teacher Azucena shares her journey reclaiming her narrative through her  field notes recap emails By: Azucena Quinones When I first began working at Biocitizen I was super excited for all of the amazing experiences I would have, from camping, exploring new trails, to working with amazing kids. I knew there would be challenges that […]

RSS New York, NY

  • Biocitizen welcomes Samantha Sanson, Field Environmental Philosophy Teacher May 10, 2022
    Biocitizen NY is pleased to welcome Samantha as a Field Environmental Philosophy teacher! She’ll be co-leading Our Place Summerschool with Yubitza Bermudez! Sam grew up hiking, snowboarding, and biking through the mountains in her home state of Colorado. Along the way, she grew to appreciate natural spaces and developed a desire to protect them. Sam […]
  • Biocitizen NY Summer 2022 Internship – Apply Now! January 12, 2022
    Biocitizen NY Summer 2022 Internship Program What is Biocitizen? Biocitizen is the only educational institution in the world devoted to teaching Field Environmental Philosophy (FEP). Our Brooklyn-based Our Place Summer School is designed to bring children into direct contact with the creatures, geologies, hydrologies, and infrastructures of the Canarsee Biome and the Hudson River Estuary. […]

RSS Concon, Chile

  • ¿POR QUÉ AMO EL CAJON DEL MAIPO? March 22, 2022
    Lugar son historias en las que vivimos. Y algunos lugares nos gustan más que otros. ¿Por qué? Ricardo Rozzi  nos cuenta una historia sobre un lugar que ama. —secundo de […]
  • Me encanta Palmar Ocoa del Parque nacional La Campana March 12, 2022
    Lugar son historias en las que vivimos. Y algunos lugares nos gustan más que otros. ¿Por qué? Yubitza Bermúdez nos cuenta una historia sobre un lugar que ama. —primero de […]